摘要 TEAM Problem 21,作为国际计算电磁学会（international compumag society）旗下用于测试电磁分析方法和软件的系列基准问题（benchmark problem）之一于1993年11月由作者团队提出。本文扼要回顾Problem 21的工业和计算电磁学背景以及持续升级的进程,系统总结基于Problem 21的建模和仿真研究以及所取得的测量和数值计算的主要结果,重点介绍Problem 21基准族结合工业应用需求的新进展。
Abstract：TEAM(testing electromagnetic analysis methods) Problem 21 was proposed by the authors in November 1993, as one of the benchmark problems officially established by the International Compumag Society. This paper briefly overviews the industrial and computational electromagnetics background and continuous progress of TEAM Problem 21, summarizes the Problem 21-based calculated and measured results, and the new developments of Problem 21 Family incorporated with the engineering science research.
程志光, 刘涛, 范亚娜, 刘兰荣, 赵志刚, 刘洋, 韩贵胜. 基于TEAM P21三维杂散场问题建模仿真与验证[J]. 电工技术学报, 2014, 29(9): 194-203.
Cheng Zhiguang, Liu Tao, Fan Yana, Liu Lanrong, Zhao Zhigang, Liu Yang, Han Guisheng. TEAM P21-Based Validation of 3-D Stray-Field Modeling and Simulation. Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, 2014, 29(9): 194-203.
[1] Turner L R. New direction for the TEAM workshops, verification of software for 3-D electromagnetic field analysis[C]. Proceedings of the Asian TEAM Work- shop, Qiandaohu, China, 1992: 6-15. [2] Proceedings of the European TEAM workshop and international seminar on electromagnetic field analysis, Oxford, England, 1990: 23-25. [3] Ida N. The TEAM workshops: fourth round[C]. Procee- dings of the TEAM workshop on computation of applied electromagnetics in materials, 1993: 9-12. [4] Verification of Software for 3-D Electromagnetic Field Analysis[C]. Proceedings of the TEAM workshop- Qiandaohu International Academic Publishers, 1992. [5] Electromagnetic Field Problems and Applications[C]. Proceedings of the ICEF-1996 International Academic Publishers, 1997. [6] Electromagnetic Field Problems and Applications[C]. Proceedings of the ICEF-2000 International Academic Publishers, 2001. [7] Trowbridge C W. The future of TEAM: some personal thoughts(invited talk)[C]. TEAM workshop, Chengde, 2000. [8] Test problems[C]. TEAM workshops 1988. [9] TEAM Benchmark Problems. [Online]. available: www. compumag. org/TEAM. [10] Cheng Z, Hu Q, Gao S, et al. An engineering-oriented loss model(Problem 21)[C]. Proceedings of the Interna- tional TEAM Workshop, Miami, 1993: 137-143. [11] Nakata T, Muramutsu K. Has the 3D magnetic field analysis come into practical application[C]. CBMAG, 1995: 7-12. [12] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Forghani B, et al. Extended progress in TEAM problem 21 family[J]. COMPEL, 2014, 33(1/2): 234-244. [13] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Forghani B, et al. 3-D finite element modeling and validation of power frequency multi-shielding effect[J]. IEEE Transactions on Mag- netics, 2012, 48(2): 243-246. [14] Zheng W, Cheng Z. Efficient finite element simulation for GO silicon steel laminations using inner-constrained laminar seperation[J]. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 2012, 48(8): 2277-2283. [15] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Forghani B, et al. Effect of variation of B-H properties on both iron loss and flux in silicon steel lamination[J]. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 2011, 47(5): 1346-1349. [16] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Forghani B, et al. Effect of excitation patterns on both iron loss and flux in solid and laminated steel configurations[J]. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 2010, 46(8): 3185-3188. [17] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Forghani B, et al. Analysis and measurements of iron loss and flux inside silicon steel laminations[J]. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 2009, 45(3): 1222-1225. [18] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Yang S, et al. Eddy current and loss analysis of multi-steel configuration and validation[J]. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 2007, 43(4): 1737-1740. [19] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Yang S, et al. Loss spectrum and electromagnetic behavior of Problem 21 family[J]. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 2006, 42(4): 1467- 1470. [20] Cheng Z, Hao R, Takahashi N, et al. Engineering- oriented benchmarking of Problem 21 family and experimental verification[J]. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 2004, 40(2): 1394-1397. [21] Takahashi N, Sakura T, Cheng Z. Nonlinear analysis of eddy current and hysteresis losses of 3-D stray field loss model(Problem 21)[J]. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 2001, 37(5): 3672-3675. [22] Gao S, Wu M, He H, et al. Problem 21 + : slotted non- magnetic steel plate driven by Problem 21’s source[C]. Proceedings of the ICEF, Yichang, Electromagnetic field problems and applications, 1996: 366-370. [23] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Gao S, et al. Loss analysis based on revised version of TEAM Problem 21[C]. 1999. [24] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Hu Q, et al. TEAM-based benchmark family: Problem 21/21+/21*[C]. 4th IEE CEM, UK, 2002. [25] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Yan S, et al. Proposal of Problem 21-based shielding model(Problem 21’)[C]. Proceedings of the TEAM Workshop, Shenyang, 2005: 15-20. [26] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Liu S, et al. Benchmarking- based approach to engineering stray-field loss problems,. ACES 2006, Miami, USA. 2006. [27] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Yang S, et al. Analysis and measurement of iron loss and linkage flux inside nonlinear magnetic steel[J]. Electromagnetic field problems and applications-I, TSI press series, USA, 2008, 22: 363-366. [28] Cheng Z, Gao S, Wang J, et al. Loss evaluation of non-magnetic tie-plates in transformers[J]. COMPEL, 1998, 17(1/2/3): 347-351. [29] 程志光, 高桥则雄, 博扎德·弗甘尼, 等. 电气工程电磁热场模拟与应用[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2009. [30] 程志光, 胡启凡, 高桥则雄, 等. 国际TEAM Problem 21基准族及工程涡流问题模拟[J]. 中国工程科学, 2007, 9(7): 38-46. Cheng Zhiguang, Hu Qifan, Takahashi N, et al. TEAM Problem 21 benchmark Family and modeling of engineering eddy current problems[J]. Engineering Sciences, 2007, 9(7): 38-46. [31] 程志光, 高生, 李琳. 电气工程涡流问题的分析与验证（国家自然科学基金研究专著）[M]. 北京: 高等教育出版社, 2001. [32] 程志光, 胡启凡, 高生, 等. 模拟三维杂散损耗的第21国际基准问题[J]. 中国电机工程学报, 1995, 15(3): 150-157. Cheng Zhiguang, Hu Qifan, Gao Sheng, et al. TEAM benchmark Problem 21 for modeling 3-D stray-field loss[J]. Proceedings of the CSEE, 1995, 15(3): 150- 157. [33] 李琳, 崔翔, 苑津莎, 等. 双标量磁位的表面阻抗法[J]. 中国电机工程学报, 1996, 16(2): 87-91. Li Lin, Cui Xiang, Yuan Jinsha, et al. A surface impedance method using two scalar magnetic potentials [J]. Proceedings of the CSEE, 1996, 16(2): 87-91. [34] 高生, 刘志光, 吴明训, 等. 构件杂散损耗问题的分析和基准模拟试验[J]. 变压器, 1997, 34(2): 3-7. Gao Sheng, Liu Zhiguang, Wu Mingxun, et al. Stray- field loss analysis of transformer parts and benchmark validation[J]. Transformer, 1997, 34(2): 3-7. [35] 程志光, 高生, 胡启凡, 等. 钢中涡流和磁滞损耗问题[J]. 变压器, 1999, 36(9): 1-5. Cheng Zhiguang, Gao Sheng, Hu Qifan, et al. Evaluation of eddy current and hysteresis loss in steel parts[J]. Transformer, 1999, 36(9): 1-5. [36] Biro O, Preis K. Solution of TEAM benchmark problem 21(an engineering-oriented loss model)[C]. Procee- dings of the International TEAM Workshop, Aix-Les- Bains, France, 1994: 25-27. [37] Cheng Z, Hu Q, Gao S, et al. On the benchmark solution of a typical engineering loss problem[C]. 10th Annual Review of Progress in Applied Computa- tional Electromagnetics, Monterey, 1994: 335-342. [38] Cheng Z, Hu Q, Gao S, et al. Supplementary report on problem 21[C]. Proceedings of the International TEAM Workshop, Aix-Les-Bains, France, 1994: 37-47. [39] Nakata T, Takahashi N, Fujiwara K, et al. Analysis of an engineering-oriented loss model(Problem 21)[C]. Proceedings of the TEAM workshop, Seoul, 1994: 51-55. [40] Nakata T, Takahashi N, Fujiwara K, et al. Analysis of flux and eddy current distribution of 3-D stray-field loss model(Problem 21)[C]. Proceedings of the Interna- tional TEAM Workshop, Aix-Les-Bains, France, 1994: 21-24. [41] Bastos J P, Ida N, Mesquita R C, et al. Problem 21: solution using edge elements and a vector potential A[C]. Proceedings of the International TEAM Workshop, Berlin, 1995: 71-75. [42] Cheng Z, Hu Q, Gao S, et al. Stray- field loss analysis and measurement(Problem 21)[C]. Proceedings of the International TEAM Workshop, Berlin, 1995: 62-66. [43] Takahashi N, Nakata T, Fujiwara K, et al. Time periodic finite element analysis of Problem 21[C]. Proceedings of the International TEAM Workshop, Berlin, 1995: 56-61. [44] Gu J, Yan W, Yang Q. Computation of flux and eddy current distributions of an engineering-oriented loss model(Problem 21)[C]. Proceedings of the Interna- tional TEAM Workshop, Berlin, 1995: 52-55. [45] Li L, Cui X, Yuan J. Numerical calculation of 3D eddy current loss and magnetic field(Problem 21)[C]. Proceedings of the International TEAM Workshop, Berlin, 1995: 67-70. [46] Takhashi N, Fujiwara K, Torill T. Analysis of eddy current in slotted plate utilizing crack element[C]. Proceedings of the ICEF. Electromagnetic Field Problems and Applications, 1996: 371-375. [47] Cheng Z, Gao S, Hu Q, et al. Summary of results for Problem 21(3-D stray-field loss model)[C]. Procee- dings of the international TEAM workshop, Berlin, 1995: 76-83. [48] Fetzer J, Kurz S, Lehner G. The solution of TEAM workshop Problem 21 using BEM-FEM coupling[C]. Proceedings of the International TEAM Workshop, Okayama, 1996: 19-22. [49] Golavanov C, Marechal Y, Meunir G. Solution of TEAM workshop Problem 21[C]. Proceedings of the International TEAM Workshop, Okayama, 1996: 26-30. [50] Leonard P J, Rodger D, Ciuprina G. Solution of TEAM Problem 21[C]. Proceedings of TEAM Work- shop, Graz, 1996: 17-19. [51] Yao Y, Xie D, Bai B. The application of the modified impedance boundary condition to the Problem 21[C]. Proceedings of ICEF, Electromagnetic Field Problems and Applications,1996:376-379. [52] Lin H. Solution of TEAM workshop Problem 21 with improved sub- structure technique[C]. Proceedings of ICEF, Electromagnetic Field Problems and Applica- tions, 1996: 380-382. [53] Gao S, Liu Z, Wu M, et al. Problem 21: loss modelling and validation[C]. Proceedings of TEAM Workshop, Okayama, 1996: 23-25. [54] Ida N, Bastos J P A. Electromagnetics and calculation of fields[M]. 2nd ed. Springer, 1997: 477-480. [55] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Gao S, et al. Hysteresis loss analysis in steel based on W h -B m curve[C]. Proceedings of CICEM, Xian, China, 1999: 454-457. [56] Yao Y, Xie D, Bai B, et al. Nonlinear transient analysis and nonlinear surface impedance method of TEAM Problem 21[C]. Proceedings of ICEF-2000, Electro- magnetic Field Problems and Applications, 2001. [57] Hu Y, Tang R. T-φ-φm+GTM method for 3-D unbounded eddy current analysis(Problem 21)[C]. Proceedings of ICEF-2000, Electromagnetic Field Problems and Applications, 2000. [58] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Gao S, et al. Some new developments of Problem 21[C]. Proceedings of the international TEAM workshop, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 1997: 21-24. [59] Takahashi N. Calculation of iron loss of engineering oriented loss model(Problem 21)[C]. Proceedings of the international TEAM workshop, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 1997: 25-26. [60] Takahashi N, Fujiwara K, Sugiyama K, et al. Verifica- tion of eddy current analysis of engineering oriented loss model(Problem 21)[C]. Proceedings of the ACES, USA, 1998: 779-786. [61] Sebestyen I, Kuczmann M. Investigation of different approaches for iron loss prediction methods using TEAM Problem 21[C]. Record of the 15th Compumag Conference on the Computation of Electromagnetic Fields, Shenyang, 2005, 2: 268-269. [62] Ishibashi K, Andjelic Z, Pusch D. Nonlinear eddy current analysis by BEM equation utilizing adaptive technique[J]. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 2009, 45(3): 1020-1023. [63] Cheng Z, Hu Q, Takahashi N, et al. Forghani. Stray- field modeling in transformers[C]. International Collo- quium Transformer Research and Asset Management, Cavtat, Croatia, 2009. [64] Cheng Z, Takahashi N, Forghani B, et al. Engineering- oriented benchmarking and application-based magnetic material modeling in transformer research[C]. Interna- tional Colloquium Transformer Research and Asset Management, Dubrovnik, Croatia, 2012. [65] Biro O, Pries K, Richter K R. Various FEM formula- tion for the calculation of the calculation of transient 3D eddy currents in nonlinear media[J]. IEEE Transac- tions on Magnetics, 1995, 31(3): 1307-1312. [66] 谢德馨, 程志光, 杨仕友, 等. 对当前计算电磁学发展的观察与思考—参加COMPUMAG2011会议有感[J]. 电工技术学报, 2013, 28(1): 136-141. Xie Dexin, Cheng Zhiguang, Yang Shiyou, et al. Observation and consideration on the current develop- ment of computa- tional electromagnetics-in perspective of COMPUMAG 2011[J]. Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, 2013, 28(1): 136-141. [67] Xie D, Cheng Z. Modeling of electrical steel sheet in computational electromagnetics[C]. World Automation Congress, 2008: 1-5 [68] IEC TR 62383—2006: Determination of magnetic loss under magnetic polarization waveforms including higher harmonic components. measurement, modeling and calculation methods[S]. 2006. [69] IEEE Std 1597. 1TM—2008: IEEE standard for validation of computational electromagnetics computer modeling and simulation[S]. 2008.
2014, Vol. 29 
